Education should induce thinking, not merely remembering

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Several years ago, I came across the remarks of a critical thinker, probably Zambian, judging by his examples, who expressed profound misgivings about the education Westerners had introduced in Africa. He complained that it took learners from practice to theory, rather than grounding theory in practical experience. Worse still, he argued, it encouraged memorisation at the expense of independent thought.

His observations were compelling. He suggested, provocatively, that our doctors were little more than distributors of Panadol. The criticism raised an important question: are we educating people to think, investigate and solve problems, or merely training them to reproduce information?

Our education system undoubtedly needs a far-reaching overhaul to remain relevant to society's changing needs. Yet, in our eagerness to discard what appears irrelevant, we should not overlook the less obvious value of certain approaches. Some knowledge may have no immediate practical application, but acquiring it can equip the mind for future challenges.

We may never use, in daily life, the knowledge that Senzangakhona was the father of Shaka Zulu, or that the Nile is Africa's longest river. Nevertheless, the educational process through which we acquired such facts should have equipped us to seek and absorb other, more useful knowledge. Education's real value lies not merely in the facts deposited in our minds, but in the intellectual tools we develop along the way.

The schools I attended offered no music lessons. Yet, drawing on learning habits acquired through the education system, albeit subconsciously, I taught myself to read musical notation. Today, I can open almost any hymn book and sing a hymn I have never heard before, provided its tune is notated.

While studying in England, I attended a church where people were once invited to join a choir supporting a Gospel musician launching an album. I registered. At our first meeting, we received booklets containing about fifteen properly notated pieces. We were instructed to study them at home and return a week later. Nobody taught us the music; each singer was expected to learn independently.

The production was mounted on an impressive scale. Several performances took place, culminating at the celebrated Royal Albert Hall. Despite never having received formal music tuition at school, I could participate confidently alongside people who had studied music. I had acquired the capacity to learn what I needed, when I needed it.

That is one of education's most valuable outcomes: the ability to continue learning throughout life. No education system can impart all the knowledge every learner will require. The range would be virtually limitless, because individuals follow different paths and encounter different demands. Practical knowledge cannot be packaged in a universal formula. Besides, knowledge is constantly changing. By the time students complete their studies, some of what they learnt may already be outdated.

Between Standards 2 and 5, I learnt several poems that remain in my memory. True, I have never applied “Cats sleep anywhere, any table, any chair…” in my professional life. Yet learning those verses exercised my young mind, strengthened my memory, and introduced me to the pleasures of language. These are worthwhile benefits, even if they do not translate directly into an occupational skill.

Mental development, like physical fitness, often results from activities that bear little resemblance to the tasks for which an individual is being prepared. A boxer jogs and uses a treadmill, although neither activity resembles a boxing match. Such exercise nevertheless develops stamina and conditioning that prove useful in the ring.

Similarly, knowing that Mount Kilimanjaro is Africa's highest peak has no obvious connection with medicine. Yet acquiring, retaining and retrieving information helps develop a mind capable of handling demanding knowledge. A future doctor must remember and reason through complex procedures; education should cultivate those intellectual capacities.

A sound education should also kindle an appetite for discovery. My seemingly elementary Standard 7 science lessons awakened a lasting fascination with astronomy and space science. In later years, I pursued the subject enthusiastically, following one line of enquiry after another. Were I living in the United States, I might well be knocking on NASA's door in pursuit of a career.

As we search within our education systems, therefore, we should look beyond the immediate usefulness of individual subjects. We should ask whether they encourage learners to question and reason logically; equip them to direct their own development; awaken a lasting hunger for knowledge; and exercise their minds sufficiently. An education that achieves these ends does more than prepare people for their first jobs. It prepares them to keep learning, adapting, and thinking long after they have left the classroom.

That distinction should guide every serious discussion about what schools ought to teach.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap