Who is a bona fide Malawian?

Reading Time: 3 minutes

A man named Masugzo Gabriel Matibili, believed to have come from the northern part of what is now Malawi, travelled to seek work in what we today call Zimbabwe. At the time, neither Malawi nor, possibly, Nyasaland existed as a political entity. While working there as a labourer, Matibili married into the Karigamombe clan and fathered several children. One was Robert, who later took the surname Mugabe from the man who brought him up, his biological father having reportedly abandoned the family. Raised as a devout Catholic and educated by the Church, Robert eventually became the first indigenous leader of independent Zimbabwe.

Another family associated with Malawi, the Kaundas, was sent to Northern Rhodesia as missionaries by the Livingstonia Mission. Their son, Kenneth, would become so deeply involved in that territory’s politics as to become its first President. When the family moved, neither Malawi nor Zambia existed as an independent country. These stories invite us to ask some searching questions: was Robert Mugabe any less Zimbabwean because his father came from elsewhere? Was Kenneth Kaunda not truly Zambian? What, in fact, makes someone a bona fide national of an African country—or of any country?

In 1959, a young Kenyan won a scholarship to study economics in the United States. He began his undergraduate studies at the University of Hawaii and later pursued postgraduate studies at Harvard University. During his time in America, he met and briefly married an American woman, Stanley Ann Dunham. Their son, Barack Obama, was born of that union.

Americans accepted Obama as a genuine American, eligible to seek the highest office in the land. He went on to become the forty-fourth President of the United States. His citizenship by birth, rather than his father’s place of origin, was central to his claim to belong. By the same reasoning, Mugabe was Zimbabwean because he was born and raised in Zimbabwe; Kaunda, likewise, was Zambian.

Could a white South African become President of post-apartheid South Africa? If that person enjoyed sufficient public support and met the constitutional requirements, why should anything else stand in the way? People born in South Africa are South African, irrespective of ancestry. The country’s history, like that of the United States, is shaped by successive migrations. The Khoikhoi and San peoples were among its earliest inhabitants; Bantu-speaking communities migrated southwards over many centuries. Jan van Riebeeck established a Dutch settlement at the Cape in 1652, long before the rise of Shaka Zulu’s military kingdom. South Africa is a country whose population and identity have been formed by people arriving at different times.

Malawi is no exception. Are the people commonly called Asians, who own shops in Limbe, Lilongwe and Mzuzu, Malawian? Of course they are—or ought to be—if they have made this country their home and meet the requirements for citizenship. Indians, Pakistanis, and Sri Lankans arrived during British rule, in the nineteenth century, to help construct the railway linking Nyasaland with Mozambique. Their presence predates that of some families from Mozambique who later came to work on estates in some Malawian districts and settled there. The latter have, in many respects, become woven into local communities, while people of Indian, Pakistani, or Sri Lankan descent are still too often treated as outsiders. That distinction need not persist. Those who wish to become Malawian citizens should be able to do so without unnecessary obstacles. If they respect our laws, they should enjoy the opportunity to participate fully in the country’s social and political life.

I do not know whether a person born in Malawi to a foreign father would readily be accepted as a presidential candidate. Such a person might be legally eligible, yet political opponents could seize upon their parentage to question their legitimacy. Perhaps we are less accommodating than our American counterparts. We attach excessive importance to ancestry and birthplace. Even among Malawians, it has become common to ask which district someone comes from before deciding whether they deserve certain opportunities or privileges. This is a sad and divisive habit.

A search within our histories would reveal that we are all migrants, though our journeys began at different times. The Akafula are often identified as the earliest inhabitants of the land now called Malawi. Bantu-speaking peoples came from elsewhere and gradually settled here. Our varied origins should not become grounds for exclusion. What matters is that we make Malawi our shared home, respect its laws, integrate into its society, and are free to contribute to its progress. Belonging should be measured not by the distant origins of our ancestors, but by our commitment to the country we all call our common home.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap