The West should report truthfully about Africa

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Some twenty years or so ago, I wrote an article entitled ‘A Camera May Lie’, in which I drew readers’ attention to the numerous tricks photographers and photo editors can, and frequently do, employ to produce images bearing little or no resemblance to reality. Photo editing has since blossomed into a celebrated profession, thanks largely to sophisticated software such as Photoshop and, more recently, artificial intelligence (AI), which can generate remarkably convincing images from simple instructions. In capable hands, these technologies are invaluable creative tools. In the wrong hands, however, they can become instruments of deception, distorting reality beyond recognition and making it increasingly difficult to distinguish fact from fabrication. In an age when AI can manufacture plausible scenes in seconds, critical judgement is no longer optional; it is essential to informed citizenship.

Before the advent of Photoshop, doctoring a photograph was a painstaking undertaking. Removing an unwanted object or incorporating something that had never appeared in the original image demanded considerable skill and patience. Small wonder, then, that the familiar saying ‘the camera never lies’ gained widespread acceptance. Today, that reassuring maxim has lost much of its credibility. Photographs, particularly those circulating on social media, deserve to be scrutinised rather than swallowed whole.

In my earlier article, I demonstrated this possibility by using Photoshop to create an image in which Blantyre’s Victoria Avenue appeared to run alongside a tea plantation. Anyone familiar with Victoria Avenue will appreciate the absurdity: tea bushes are nowhere to be found in its immediate vicinity. Yet, with a little digital ingenuity, an entirely fictitious scene could be made to look convincing. Pictures, it seems, can now tell lies with remarkable confidence.

Those determined to misrepresent the truth can manipulate photographs to advance their own narratives, sometimes fundamentally altering the meaning of an event. What appears before our eyes may not be what actually happened; what has been excluded can be just as significant as what remains.

A few years ago, a group of young climate activists attended the World Economic Forum in Switzerland. Climate change featured prominently on that year’s agenda, prompting the organisers to invite the young campaigners, among them a Ugandan activist named Vanessa Nakate. Following a press conference in Davos, the group gathered for a photograph, capturing young people united by a common cause.

The following day, however, a newspaper published the photograph with Nakate conspicuously cropped out. Her white colleagues remained, while she alone had disappeared from the frame. The incident left her shocked and deeply distressed. In a video posted on Twitter, she struggled to contain her tears as she recounted what had happened.

‘I was cropped out of this photo! Why?’ she asked in anguish. Then came her devastating observation: ‘You didn’t just erase a photo. You erased a continent. But I am stronger than ever.’

Her words resonated far beyond the photograph itself. They spoke to a longstanding concern about Africa’s marginalisation and the persistent tendency to overlook its people’s achievements. Throughout history, African accomplishments have too often been neglected, diminished or attributed to outside influences. Sometimes, silence has accomplished the erasure; at other times, explanations have been fashioned to transfer the credit elsewhere. I have explored several such examples in earlier articles.

Consider Mansa Kankan Musa, the fourteenth-century ruler of the Mali Empire, widely regarded as one of history’s wealthiest individuals. During his pilgrimage to Mecca in 1324, his lavish entourage passed through Egypt, distributing such quantities of gold that the resulting disruption reportedly affected the metal’s value for years. His extraordinary wealth challenges conventional assumptions about Africa’s historical place in the world. Musa’s net worth has been estimated in retrospect to have been around $400 billion. Only Elon Musk has recently surpassed that figure and is reported to be the world’s first trillionaire in dollar terms.

Africa’s contribution to civilisation is evident in ancient Egypt. Some rulers were light-skinned, but between approximately 760 and 660 BC, a dynasty of Nubian, or black, pharaohs ruled Egypt. In 2008, a National Geographic writer observed that this chapter had long gone untold until archaeologists recovered the history of an African civilisation south of the Nile. Such discoveries remind us how much remains to be learnt when assumptions are challenged.

In 1988, I visited the imposing stone structures of Great Zimbabwe. When Europeans encountered the ruins, some refused to believe Africans could have built them. The white Rhodesian Government pressured archaeologists not to identify the builders as Africans. Yet truth cannot be buried beneath prejudice or political convenience.

Let us keep searching within Africa, uncovering neglected history and celebrating the flashes of brilliance that deserve their rightful place in the human story.

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top
Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap